Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake and Sequel Podcast

Jade Anderson

“To remake? Or not to remake?" With all the sequels cluttering up the modern cinema and television scene, how many of them actually hold up to the original? With regard to remaking film and TV, we wonder:
What is it all for? Is it really worth it? Are these remake-happy, sequelphile producers and directors going too far? Has originality, in fact, got in the way of the proverbial dodo himself?
And most of all, we ask of our favorite films; “Shall we compare thee?”
Jade and Paul here, asking you to join us our deep-dive journey into the world of our favorite filmmakers, actors, screenwriters and cinematic geniuses. We will explore our cfavorite film and television gems and compare them to their modernized, re-imagined and serialized counterparts. We'll then decide which one gets to live on and which one gets the kiss off, baby!
We intend to boldly go where no Podcaster has gone before. So allow us to light the way on a perilous trip down remake lane and many sequel rabbit holes. We'll find out if Dorothy was right all along; Is there truly no place like home? One thing's for sure Luis, this looks like the beginning of a beautiful friendship…
Leave us your feedback to read and respond to on the podcast. Send your thoughts, opinions and episode recommendations to Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com
We accept written feedback and voice messages, so be brave and let your voice be heard!
...Here's talkin' to you kid!
Check out Jade's other podcasts!
Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel Podcast
Murder Magnets -A Poker Face Podcast
Dead to Us- A Dead to Me Podcast
Follow Jade on social media:
Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8green
Youtube:@JadeAndersonactor Website:Jade-anderson.com

Paul's trivia podcast - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud
Follow Paul on social media:
Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfix
Instagram- @quizfix
Facebook- Quizfix
Paul's FB- PaulJensen
Paul's band on FB- The Profits read less
TV & FilmTV & Film

Episodes

MVP: Columbo Villains- Cassidy vs. Culp
22-10-2023
MVP: Columbo Villains- Cassidy vs. Culp
Watch the video of this podcast. Extended cut video on Patreon! Patrons get early access, Bonus episodes, and listen ad-free! patreon.com/perfectlymarvelouspodcast3rd installment in our MVP series: Jade and Paul shamelessly gush about Colombo and deep-dive into villain territory! Who reigns supreme? Cassidy or Culp? We discuss 6 episodes in total!Jack Cassidy's episodes – Murder by the Book S1E1, Publish or Perish S3E4, and Now You See Him S5E5.Robert Culp's episodes – Death Lends a Hand S1E2, The Most Crucial Game S2E3, and Double Exposure S3E4. Get your rewatch on and join the party because this one was definitely a favorite to record! Enjoy! XOXO 💚Leave us your feedcrack on any films we've covered or send us suggestions for future episodes by emailing:Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice messages accepted!Facebook group:Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Instagram: @ShallWeCompareThee...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Follow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube- @JadeAndersonactor Website- Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Shall We Compare Thee- A Remake &Sequel PodcastPerfectly Marvelous! Only Murders in the BuildingPerfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfix Facebook- Quizfix Paul's trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensen Paul's band on FB- The Profits
Barbie(2023) vs. Saturday Night Fever(1977)..sort of
12-08-2023
Barbie(2023) vs. Saturday Night Fever(1977)..sort of
This is a follow up convo to our first podcast Reviewing Barbie (2023) written and directed by Greta Gerwig/Noah Bomback starring Margot Robbie, and Ryan Gosling-- compared to Life-Size 2 (2018) starring Tyra Banks, and Francia Raisa.Go to Patreon to listen ad-free and also watch the video of this and all our other episodes! patreon.com/perfectlymarvelouspodcast Leave us your feedback on Barbie, Life-Size or any films we've covered or send us suggestions for future episodes by emailing:Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice messages accepted!Facebook group:Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Instagram: @ShallWeCompareTheeNext episode we’ll be Comparing THE SHOP AROUND THE CORNER 1940 starring Margaret Sullivan and Jimmy Stewart, IN THE GOOD OLD SUMMERTIME 1949 starring Judy Garland and Van Johnson, and YOU’VE GOT MAIL 1998, with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. Subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss it!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Follow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube- @JadeAndersonactor Website- Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfix Facebook- Quizfix Paul's trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensen Paul's band on FB- The Profits
Barbie (2023) vs. Life-Size 2 (2018)
02-08-2023
Barbie (2023) vs. Life-Size 2 (2018)
Timestamps below) Reviwing Barbie (2023) written and directed by Greta Gerwig Noah Bomback starring Margot, Robbie, and Ryan Gosling-- compared to Life-Size 2 (2018) starring Tyra Banks, and Francia Raisa.Go to Patreon to listen ad-free and also watch the video of this and all our other episodes! patreon.com/perfectlymarvelouspodcast Leave us your feedback on Barbie, Life-Size or any films we've covered or send us suggestions for future episodes by emailing:Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice messages accepted!Facebook group:Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Instagram: @ShallWeCompareTheeNext episode we’ll be Comparing THE SHOP AROUND THE CORNER 1940 starring Margaret Sullivan and Jimmy Stewart, IN THE GOOD OLD SUMMERTIME 1949 starring Judy Garland and Van Johnson, and YOU’VE GOT MAIL 1998, with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. Subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss it!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Timestamps (might be offset a few min due to ads):Timestamps:6:09 – Barbie mini-quiz14:57 – Life Size 2: A Christmas Eve32:49 – Barbie1:33:33 - AwardsFollow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube- @JadeAndersonactor Website- Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfix Facebook- Quizfix Paul's trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensen Paul's band on FB- The Profits
Indiana Jones: Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) vs. Dial of Destiny (2023)
17-07-2023
Indiana Jones: Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) vs. Dial of Destiny (2023)
(Timestamps below) Well this was an epic event! Life changing!! (for Jade anyway) Look out for our discussion of the other Indiana Jones films: Temple of Doom, The Last Crusade and The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull on our Patreon where you can listen ad-free and also watch the video of this and all our other episodes! patreon.com/perfectlymarvelouspodcast Leave us your feedback on Indiana Jones, or any films we've covered or send us suggestions for future episodes by emailingShallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice messages accepted!Facebook group:Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Instagram: @ShallWeCompareTheeNext episode we’ll be Comparing THE SHOP AROUND THE CORNER 1940 starring Margaret Sullivan and Jimmy Stewart, IN THE GOOD OLD SUMMERTIME 1949 starring Judy Garland and Van Johnson, and YOU’VE GOT MAIL 1998, with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. Subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss it!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Timestamps (might be offset a few min due to ads):1:32 - trailer33:42 - Discussion starts1:29:08 - AwardsFollow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube- @JadeAndersonactor Website- Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfix Facebook- Quizfix Paul's trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensen Paul's band on FB- The Profits
Peter Pan and Wendy(2023) Peter Pan(1953) Peter Pan(2003) Hook(1991) Mary Martin's Peter Pan(1955/1960)
02-07-2023
Peter Pan and Wendy(2023) Peter Pan(1953) Peter Pan(2003) Hook(1991) Mary Martin's Peter Pan(1955/1960)
(Timestamps below) It's a Peter Pan-athon! We review and compare 5 Peter Pan films: Disney's Peter Pan cartoon (1953), Disney's remake; Peter Pan & Wendy (2023), Peter Pan (2003), Hook (1991) and Mary Martin's made for TV musical: Peter Pan 1960, Mary Martin YoutubeJoin our Facebook group! Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Follow us on Instagram! @ShallWeCompareTheeWatch the video of this episode- patreon.com/perfectlymarvelouspodcast The following episode will be Comparing Indiana Jones Raiders of the Lost Arc to the latest Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny, 2023- now in theaters!! If you have thoughts on any or all of these films or suggestions for future episodes, please send your feedback to Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice message accepted!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Timestamps (might be off 2-3 min due to ads):3:44 -Film trailers5:03 - JM Barrie and Jade/Paul's history with Peter Pan20:57 - Peter Pan (1953)39:14- Peter Pan (Musical - 1960)1:02:52- Peter Pan (2003)1:27:46 - Peter Pan and Wendy (2023)1:42:54 - Hook (1991)2:05:48 - Jade/Paul pick fantasy Peter Pan cast2:20:00 - Listener FeedbackFollow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube- @JadeAndersonactor Website- Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfix Facebook- Quizfix Paul's trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensen Paul's band on FB- The ProfitsPeter Pan News Links/References for this episode:J. M. Barrie documentary The making of Peter Pan Doc 1953Behind the scenes of Peter Pan (2003) | FULL HD | Part 1/2 Peter Pan 1924 (full silent film)Mary Martin's Peter Pan, 1955 full film Jason Isaacs Talks Peter Pan (2003) and Playing Captain Hook
Psycho (1960) vs. (1998)
20-06-2023
Psycho (1960) vs. (1998)
Paul and Jade talk Psycho! Comparing/contrasting Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho (1960) to Gus Van Sant's remake; Psycho (1998)FYI: Psycho(1960) will be leaving Netflix on July 1, 2023 so get your rewatch in! If you haven't seen Psycho (1998) and don't wish to pay for it, no worries, CLICK HERE for a video of both films spliced together so you can get a fair enough idea of what we're talking about. Enjoy!Join our Facebook group! Shall We Compare Thee? A Remake & Sequel Group Follow us on Instagram! @ShallWeCompareTheeOur next episode will be on Peter Pan! We'll compare Disney's cartoon (1953) to Peter Pan & Wendy (2023) also discuss Peter Pan (2003), Hook (1991) and Mary Martin's made for TV musical: Peter Pan 1960, Mary Martin YoutubeThe following episode will be Comparing Little Shop of Horrors (1960) starring Jack Nicholson to the Little Shop of Horrors (1986) musical directed by Frank Oz.If you have thoughts on any or all of these films, pleave us your feedback!We'd LOVE to read and respond to your comments so send your thoughts, opinions and recommendations to Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com or on Facebook and Instagram. Written feedback or voice message!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Time stamps (will be offset by 1-2 min due to ads- SORRY!)17:39 - start discussion/hotel scene30:41 - The office/driving/car lot57:44 - Marion arrives at the Bates Motel/Parlor scene1:34:25 - Shower/Clean-up Scene1:54:28 - Arbogast, Sam and Lila2:02:34 - Arbogast goes to the Bates Motel2:17:00 - Sam and Lila go to the Bates Motel2:39:13 - Psychiatrist explains it all2:43:50 - AwardsFollow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube:@JadeAndersonactor Website:Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfixFacebook- Quizfix Trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensenPaul's band on FB- The ProfitsPsycho links/references:Documentaries-1960:The Making Of Psycho Psycho 1960 - Behind the Scenes - 'Psycho' Sound ​​The Psycho Legacy78/52: Hitchcock's shower scene 1998:Psycho Path: The Making of Psycho 1998 - YouTube The Making of Psycho (1997) - transcript - The Alfred Hitchcock WikiAudio:Audible- Alfred Hitchcock, the making of psycho audiobook Inside Psycho on Apple PodcastsPsycho on Youtube:Psycho/s (both movies spliced together)Psycho (1960/1998): Side-by-Side Comparison - YouTubeSlavoj Žižek presents ‘The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema’ by Sophie Fiennes [PART1] Slavoj Zizek Explains Freudian Theory in Hitchcock's: Psycho (1960) | Psychoanalysis Bird Symbolism in Psycho: Women as Prey Understanding Psycho: The UncannyManiacs and Psychos - Mental Illness in Horror Movies | Renegade CutPSYCHO (1960) Uncut Comparison - Footage Restored after 60 Years Hitchcock on Youtube:Alfred Hitchcock On Mastering Cinematic TensionHow Hitchcock Creates SuspenseAlfred Hitchcock: Dialogue versus Pure Cinema | Film Analysis Alfred Hitchcock: The Rules of Visual StorytellingFilm Techniques of Alfred Hitchcock (2nd Edition) Suspense Documentary I Alfred Hitchcock: Master of Suspense (2013) I Retrospective Articles:The Savage id- Camile Paglia-on Hitch's influence Ending of Hitchcock's 'Psycho' (Oedipal complex)Freud's Concept of the Unconscious - Hitchcock's PsychoPsycho movie review & film summary (1998) | Roger EbertAFI|Catalog - PsychoVariety: 100 best movies of all time Variety: Psycho review Joblo:Variety names Psycho greatest FilmGus Van Sant Explains Why He Remade Psycho (collider.com)Psycho! – Music and Manipulation in Hitchcock’s Great Comedy | Humor in AmericaHitchcock and food articles:A culinary guide to Al
Psycho 1960 & 1998 Trailer
08-06-2023
Psycho 1960 & 1998 Trailer
Hey, Paul and Jade here! We are so excited to release our first episode where we will be talking all things Psycho:The cast and crew, production, making-of, behind-the-scenes, trivia and of course comparing/contrasting Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho,1960 to the Gus Van Sant shot-for-shot remake; Psycho,1998.FYI: Psycho, 1960 will be leaving Netflix on July 1, 2023 so get your rewatch in! If you haven't seen it, psycho, 1998 and don't wish to pay for it, no worries, CLICK HERE for a video of both films spliced together so you can get a fair enough idea of what we're talking about. Enjoy! Our next episode will be on Peter Pan! We will compare and contrast The Disney cartoon-1953, Hook-1991, Mary Martin's made for TV musical ( Peter Pan 1960, Mary Martin restored)and of course Disney's latest live action Peter Pan & Wendy- 2023.The following episode will be on Little shop of horrors! Comparing Little Shop of Horrors- 1960, starring Jack Nicholson to the Little Shop of Horrors-1986 musical directed by Frank Oz.If you have thoughts on any or all of these films, pleave us your feedback!We'd LOVE to read and respond to your comments on the podcast. So please join in the conversation with us! Send your thoughts, opinions and recommendations to Shallwecomparethee@gmail.com. We accept written feedback and especially love voice messages, so be brave and let your voice be heard!...Here's talkin' to you, kid. Cheers!Follow Jade on social media:Instagram- @Jadethenakedlady Tiktok- @Jade8greenYoutube:@JadeAndersonactor Website:Jade-anderson.comJade's other podcasts:Perfectly marvelous! -A Marvelous Mrs. Maisel PodcastMurder Magnets -A Poker Face PodcastDead to Us- A Dead to Me PodcastFollow Paul on social media:Paul's pub quiz/trivia site- quizfixInstagram- @quizfixFacebook- Quizfix Trivia podcast with Monika - Stream Quizfix Podcast on SoundCloud Paul's FB- PaulJensenPaul's band on FB- The Profits