1. It Must Be Believed To Be SeenChristian Borle, Emma Pfaeffle, Michael Wartella, Trista Dollison, F. Michael Haynie & Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Broadway Ensemble
4. Strike That, Reverse ItChristian Borle, Emma Pfaeffle, Michael Wartella, Trista Dollison & F. Michael Haynie
5. Webster AvenueAriana DeBose, Bobby Conte, Bradley Gibson, Gilbert L. Bailey II, Christiani Pitts, Trista Dollison, 'A Bronx Tale' Original Broadway Ensemble, Alan Menken & Glenn Slater